Osteria Cotta in New York

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• en

  Matthew Arthur

  :: 03 June 2018 21:16:45

  Went here today for the first time today. I also went here for the last time today. They have a bottomless $26 brunch beverage that they advertise on the menu. After taking our orders (various brunch eats and three bottomless beverages), the server returned to the table to let us know that "effective today if anyone orders bottomless beverages, then everyone must have bottomless beverages". Since I don't often drink, I pushed back and she said she'd check with her manager. She returned to tell me that I'd have to pay for bottomless beverages, but that I could have orange juice or tea - but I'd have to pay. WHAT?!?! They forced me into paying $26 for beverages which I didn't even want. Terrible policy. It's like they asked Donald Trump to come up with a solution to some imaginary problem. The food was eh. Nothing special. Restaurant was empty when it probably should have been packed. Perhaps a sign that this isn't the spot that management thinks it is. I definitely won't be back.

• en

  Scott K

  :: 30 May 2018 16:04:19

  Been going here for years. Always great service and food is delicious and options for when you're hungry or just want something light. Great ambiance, very cozy with classic old world charm. Never too loud. Upstairs is very unique with private nooks and welcoming furnishings. Highly recommend.

• 

  BJ FitzGerald

  :: 03 April 2018 20:01:44

  Firstly, the food is excellent. I brought my family there on a Monday night and while it was a slow part of the evening, the staff seated us in a beautiful spot and treated us wonderfully. Service was fast and the server was so kind to my young children. I will definitely eat there again.

• 

  Howard Packham

  :: 03 March 2018 15:24:54

  Casual Italian with a broad menu and huge seating space. There’s a covered outdoor area, a decent space around the bar, and two large rooms upstairs. The pizza was well put together and quick to the table. There seemed to be a mix of clientele, from couples on a date, small party groups, and a few families with children. Everyone was made to feel comfortable and the atmosphere was welcoming.

• 

  Jenny Taylor

  :: 19 February 2018 14:05:31

  We had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. Beautiful atmosphere, excellent service and the food was delicious and reasonably priced. I also left my debit card here and didn’t realize it until the next day. I had to call and go by the restaurant on the way to the airport. Lauren was waiting for us and came out to the cab to deliver the card so we could be on our way to the airport. Great customer service!