Supreme Bakery. in West Orange

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• en

  Shalese Fuller

  :: 22 May 2018 17:09:24

  Had a very expensive disappointing experience with my cake order.. I ordered my cake in person on Saturday, my 1st question was how much notice was needed to order a cake? 2nd info was I needed it for 20-25 people.. I paid for the cake in FULL because I had a lot of other things to do. Emailed my design as requested.. On Monday pick up my 3 YES 3 SHEET CAKES, when I requested 1.. Yes my invoice had a 3 on it, but I didn't question it because 20-25 people was previously discussed.. I received a full look of deer in headlights response!! I also see you only respond to positive reviews so I expect no human response & I spent $195.00. Update on 5/22. Owner/Representative did contact me in reference to my cake order. I will continue to use Supreme Bakery.. My guest enjoyed the cake & the rest I donated.

• 

  Gi Freeman

  :: 14 May 2018 16:25:52

  I would say that they are not bad. They are actually pretty good. However in some cases I beleieve that they need a better selection of cream and toppings on their items. Many times I find myself taking of the crisco off the cakes because its too sweet. Also I kinda find that the items are not as fresh as when they first opened. Also I believe that the prices are slightly higher than expected.

• en

  Shannon

  :: 25 April 2018 02:54:00

  Supreme Bakery made a 2 tier unicorn cake for my daughter's 1st bday and it was lovely ! Might I add it taste great. I always get my specialty cake from here . I would highly recommend .

• 

  Whitney m

  :: 01 December 2017 21:02:39

  I love their cookies (salted caramel), pies, cakes and pastries , but I hate inconsistency! I just left there after a 15 minute drive, because they’re supposed to close at 9 pm. Some Friday’s I arrive at 8:55 and can find the key lime tart I love so much. I visit this bakery 1-2 times a week. Today, I got to the door at 8:53, and the doors were locked. I believe that a business should stay open as long as their posted hours. I had an entire order for my friends and would just like more consistency. This isn’t the first time it happened! So as a disappointed customer I’m finally leaving a review!

• en

  Tenzin Lama

  :: 12 November 2017 14:27:44

  The cake was simply beautiful, and was definitely worth every penny. It was perfectly sweetened, very light and fluffy, and was loved by everyone! There were 30 guests and we still have leftovers, I would recommend this to anyone for any occasion. Additionally, we received such great service from the workers, one even helped carry our cake to the car and placed it carefully to prevent it from falling. Thank you so much, we will definitely come back again :)