Make My Cake in New York

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• 

  Mike Abbey

  :: 19 May 2018 23:41:22

  Stopped while on a bus trip to St. John the Devine. Excellent banana pudding, the sliced cake was fresh and moist. Wish they were closer to Staten Island, NY Wished they delivered to Staten Island, NY

• en

  Lakeisha Wilson

  :: 16 May 2018 06:08:23

  This restaurant’s follow up for special orders is HORRIBLE! I’ve heard good things about them but unfortunately they didn’t stand up to their good name!

• 

  Karina Romero

  :: 22 April 2018 09:22:58

  I’m upset the 116th location moved to 99th Street and Columbus Avenue. They said it was due to rent increase over at 116th. The Red Velvet isn’t consistent with the taste. I’ve bought Red Velvet from them 3 times and all taste different. Also, another problem I’ve i the cupcakes and slices is too dry and the taste is inconsistent. Please make your cupcakes and slices more moist and the taste better then what it is.

• en

  Margie Nix

  :: 06 April 2018 14:15:42

  Great selection of cakes & other dessert treats. Had peach cobbler but ran out of apple cobbler in the early afternoon.

• 

  Kalianthie Anastasiou

  :: 11 February 2018 21:23:59

  Such a cute local bakery, honestly one of the best slices of double chocolate cake. Unfortunately freshness is an issue sometimes. This is the third time I've purchased a croissant that is too old. The dough is no longer soft and buttery. I hate leaving bad reviews, but this needs to be checked, has also happened a few times with the cinnamon rolls and cake slices. Quality is incredibly inconsistent. I hate purchasing food and having to throw it away. BUT when they are fresh...amazing.