East Islip Bagel in East Islip

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• en

  Kathy VanDyke

  :: 24 December 2017 09:02:50

  Excellent bagels. Great staff.

• 

  Glen Fergo

  :: 06 June 2017 21:25:46

  I would give 3.5 stars if Yelp allowed it, but since I cannot I am rounding UP to balance out the negative reviews. This was my first time there. The service was excellent. The woman at the counter was friendly and professional. Two egg sandwiches on fresh bagels came to just under $9. (Normal for Long Island.) My sandwich (two scrambled with American cheese) was excellent. Eggs cooked perfectly. Cheese warm and melt. Bagel fresh and soft. Bagels were coming out of the kitchen while we waited. (I believe - but cannot swear to it - that they were hot, fresh, and prepared on-site.) Cold cuts are Boar's Head. Lunch sandwiches include salad (potato, macaroni, or coleslaw) and a beverage (coffee, hot tea, or iced tea).

• 

  Cathy Midura

  :: 25 October 2016 20:44:01

  Small shop, good bagels

• 

  Michael Carson

  :: 16 February 2015 10:50:17

  Excellent

• en

  Пользователь Google

  :: 13 March 2010 12:27:33

  These bagels are bad. If we were not in NY these bagels would be OK. We are in NY where the bagels are supposed to be the best. There was a line out the door, But probably because Stuff-A-Bagel was closed due to renovations. i paid $8.50 for 2 bagels and a drink??? WHAT!? Service was great, the bagels are the size of big donuts and the price is ridiculous. 1 Star, Sorry.