Casa Rustica in Smithtown

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• en

  Mary J Theobalt

  :: 28 May 2018 02:48:44

  My family celebrated my Fathers 75 th and my parents 55th wedding Anniversary what a disappointment. We had reservations for five pm the portions were so small it was like they ran out of food . After paying the nearly nine hundred dollar bill we had to pick up food so no one went home hungry. Needless to say we won't be returning to Casa Rustica.

• en

  Frank DeCicco

  :: 09 May 2018 07:25:49

  Excellent service. Apps were amazing. Rizzoli was great, a little too salty.

• en

  Sage Myers

  :: 23 April 2018 00:22:24

  I was excited to have classic food with some unique flavors, and just a twist enough off the norm to be adventurous. Everything I got was like tasting a knock off of a recipe. My Asparagus Au Gratin- was basic. As if the effort was made to brown the cheese, but it was disconnected from the asparagus. The salad was well done, and squash was firm. My lobster risotto was good. Not too much lobster, though. Probably wouldn't want to wait for the food. Got my dinner through doordash, but paid more than if I sat in, so thought I was paying premium price for a lot better than what I got.

• en

  lianne martin

  :: 15 February 2018 18:59:50

  Flew back to New York and our favorite restaurant to have valentines Day dinner with my husband. Casa Rustica has impeccable service, warm family feel. Came back to celebrate with the best stuffed lobster I have every had. My husband had the lobster ravioli, every meal we have had here has been excellent.

• 

  Eliatt Dilieto Jr

  :: 28 December 2017 20:56:42

  Excellent dishes with a home cooked feel. Ambience is good for just grabbing a drink and a quick bite or a more in depth evening. Service was good, even if the staff seemed a bit hurried. A busy place.