The Pie Store in Montclair

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• en

  Nicole Francoeur

  :: 09 May 2018 20:43:33

  Love love love the pies here. Sweet or savory, for dinner or dessert I love them all. And don’t forget the scones! Fresh strawberry is my favorite. Stock up on your British staples. And now they have a tea room a few doors down. Hit both places!

• 

  Nash Greene

  :: 28 April 2018 20:26:30

  The savory pies are quite flavorless and the sweet pies tend to have too much flavor. The key lime pie is too sweet, the chocolate Mousse is so rich you can only enjoy the first bite or so. The savory pies are so inconsistent in flavor I really can't continue to buy them because I never know what I'm going to get. The shepards pie is just plain and gross honestly. They need to switch their ground beef with lamb. All around inconsistent food and flavor. NOT happy with the pie store.

• 

  Andrew Jackson

  :: 24 March 2018 13:48:35

  Best savory and sweet pies ever! If you miss great British pies then this is the place for you. Also great range of other British fare that you won't find in the foreign aisle at Shoprite.

• 

  J Lee

  :: 08 February 2018 18:38:03

  The staff here is wonderful and polite. They have fresh pies to serve and frozen pies. You can also buy little treats or candies from England. My favorite is Jellie Babies. You can get savory and sweet pies! They have a very good variety of pies!

• 

  Bobby Beaton

  :: 31 January 2018 12:48:39

  This place lives up to its reputation. Great staff and easy to find location make it a wonderful destination. I can’t say enough good things about the blue cheese and sweet potato pie! The pie shop is take out only but you can order from the tea store (next door) for a great dine in experience!