Sutter's Mill in Suffern

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• 

  Michael Hickey

  :: 01 June 2018 06:59:57

  Still got great wings. Other food is Good too.

• en

  Ben Kimmel

  :: 17 May 2018 13:51:26

  Food wasnt that good and the guy behind the bar was unfriendly at best. Maybe this was because I'm not a regular or it could be for any number of reasons, but no matter what the reason is, I know I will never go back there

• en

  Michael Leonakis

  :: 30 April 2018 10:42:20

  I been going here for years. The burgers are known to locals as being the best in the county. I mostly get the cheese steaks and burgers. The cheese steak is really good. You get a good size portion for you money. The girls who work there are very nice as well. It's always packed. Great place.

• 

  michelle erev

  :: 21 April 2018 10:06:11

  I have been going to sutter’s mill for years now. Past 2 times that we’ve ordered the food, it has been very bad. The taste wasn’t the same. The wings tasted very bad (like it past it’s due date) and the kid’s burger was BURNT. I ended up making my son dinner because it was way too dry. All the food we’ve ordered (2 order of wings, 2 chicken cutlet sandwiches, and kid’s burger) was BAD! Smelled awful and tasted OLD or refried in old oil. We all woke up with bad stomachaches (last thing we ate was this dinner). Never going back! Not recommended at all!

• 

  Andrew Chalfin

  :: 11 March 2018 08:14:45

  How do I love this place? Let me count the ways. I'm a big wing guy and this place has been the stalwart establishment for as long as I can remember. On top of it the staff is always cool and quick, and other food is great too. Had corn chowder the other day perfect flavor. Nice size portions. And don't miss Tuesdays wing night.