Shelsky's of Brooklyn: Appetizing & Delicatessen in New York

🕗 opening times

comments 5

• en

  lilly bktlv

  :: 21 May 2018 14:03:10

  Best "S.A.L.M.O.N." in the States of New York! Highly recommend!

• 

  Steven Aldridge

  :: 17 May 2018 12:27:40

  Love this place. They will give you a quizzical look if you ask to put their Salmon Jerky on a bagel. I guess you're supposed to eat it by itself? But I love it. Scallion Cream Cheese + Salmon Beef Jerky + Red Onions on an Everything Bagel is my favorite. Everything else there is fantastic too.

• 

  Chris Shanks

  :: 15 May 2018 13:25:51

  So yummy. Classic Brooklyn spot. Go smoked fish.

• en

  Eric Colton

  :: 25 April 2018 10:04:02

  The "Great Gatsby" sandwich was unbelievably good. Pastrami-cured salmon with honey-mustard. Not a combination I would have dreamt up myself, but nonetheless the best thing I've tasted in recent memory. I could have easily eaten two of them. I've been here for lunch twice. The previous time I got the "Fancy Pants", which was merely ok and not particularly noteworthy. So first lunch experience garners 3 starts, and the second garners 5. Which would average 4, but the "Great Gatsby" was so exceptional it needs to be 5 overall.

• 

  M Papaya

  :: 22 April 2018 21:30:36

  Two words: salmon jerky. Is it expensive? Yes. Is it one of the best things you'll ever put in your mouth? Also yes. On sandwiches: The menu board can be hella overwhelming, especially your first time in, so I'd recommend checking it out online first. Some sandwiches are a bit forgettable (and could comparably be found elsewhere for a lower price) but my go-to here, the Great Gatsby, is, well, pretty effing great.